Tuesday, March 13, 2012

Not even a hint of racism can be tolerated

This column appears in this week's INM Irish regional newspapers.

By Michael Commane
Over the years I have heard and read about the evils of racism. It shows its ugly head from time to time. We hear stories about how people who have come to live in Ireland have suffered racist taunts.

Out walking with my dog on Friday I passed a door with 'State your name nigger' written across it. It was a goods entrance into an architect’s office. It stopped me in my step and I asked myself what sort of a moron could write something so horrible as that.

I called into the office to tell them what was written on the door. The secretary took note and said she would take action. It was new graffiti as I pass that door every day and I had not seen it before.

Anyone who reads this column will know that I have an interest in all things German. I like Germany and the Germans. But I have walked in evil places; Auschwitz, Buchenwald, Oranienburg. I have seen piles of human hair, gold fillings from human teeth. I have seen a roomful of cases containing the belongings of innocent people who thought they would need the contents for their stay in their new 'homes'.

And all this happened in one of the world's most civilised cultures, the land of Goethe, Schiller, Bach and Beethoven.

The moment we put a name on a group of people, once we single out a religious group, a nationality, a specific culture for a particular behaviour we are walking on terribly thin ice.

It's not a big step to go on and scapegoat a group for all our woes.

It's obviously a terribly easy thing to do. It might even seem to solve problems for us.

That was part of the lure of the evil of the Nazis. They promised to solve so much through their racist policy.
All forms of racism and xenophobia try to lure their listeners into the belief that those being scapegoated are the cause of all our woes.

Certainly we have every right to object to certain or particular policies of the Irish Government. We can disagree with aspects of US foreign policy, we can be critical of Israeli policy towards Palestine. Only on Friday the Israeli air force killed the leader of a Palestinian militant faction in an attack on a car in the Gaza Strip. Of course we can object to that. That's all healthy political debate.

But we can never cast aspersions on entire peoples or cultures and we must never use derogatory terms to describe a group or nation.

Some months ago after the publication of the Cloyne Report it was reported in the media that a Catholic priest preaching during Mass alluded to the fact that our Minister for Foreign Affairs was an atheist and that the Minister for Justice and Defence was a non-practising Jew.

If the priest said what was reported then it was an appalling comment, stupid too. But far worse than that. It was indeed dangerous and the reference to Mr Shatter had all the clothes of racism. It was as if to say, a Jew is one thing but a non-practising Jew was something else. And to say this in the context of the celebration of the Eucharist is really intolerable. Fortunately the priest’s congregation did issue an apology.

Over the last few years a number of murders have taken place in Germany. At the time it was generally believed that the victims were involved in crime.

It has now transpired the innocent victims were killed by neo-Nazis.
It's now Sunday and that graffiti I saw on Friday is still on those doors.

I intend to keep calling to the office until it is removed.

It's important that we never tolerate the slightest hints of any form of racism. Too many people have paid far too much at the hands of racists. And it seems we can never let down our guard in the battle against it.

In times of recession and despair racism moves about like the 'devil prowling round like a roaring lion, looking for someone to eat'.

We need to be reasonable, kind and compassionate too, and never underestimate the power of truth and logical argument.

It’s not too long ago at all since we were known as the ‘dirty Irish’ or the shop notices that read, ‘Irish need not apply’.

You’d imagine we would have learned from that. Sadly not.

5 comments:

Thomas G McCarthy said...

Michael,
as ever it is helpful to read a fresh warning against any form of racism or intolerance. I agree we need to be 'reasonable, kind and compassionate'. It is to be regretted then that you use the insulting word 'moron' to describe a person. Not even in psychological practice is that term used now - not because it does not have a technical meaning in psychologists' classification of levels of intelligence: rather, it is unacceptable since in the Umgangssprache its use indicates what can be seen as an insulting attitude to a human being.
You are also aware how thrilled I have been on occasion to avail of opportunities to work in parishes in Germany and in Switzerland and how I love speaking German. Yes, Germany is the land of Bach and Beethoven. You did not mention Richard Wagner.
There are no evil places on earth, Michael. Nor evil people. Human behaviour is capable of being described as laudable or wrong - and inappropriate behaviour must be described clearly by disciples of Christ, who hope for better from one another. No place is more sacred than another, as I am sure an iconoclast like you would admit. Nor can any location be confused with the categories of human behaviour.
Despite these serious caveats, I welcome your timely reminder to your readers, myself included.

Michael said...

Tom, I don't agree with you regarding the use of moron. The term, as a technical definition, is indeed considered as offensive within medicine, especially in psychology. Its use in common parlace, as in moronic behaviour, is both common and widely accepted.
Regarding places being evil, you are technically correct: no place is of itself evil. But places can be associated with great evil as in Dachau or Treblinka. Why were the homes of Fred and Rosemary West and Josef Fritzl razed?
Michael

Michael said...

Tom, I don't agree with you regarding the use of moron. The term, as a technical definition, is indeed considered as offensive within medicine, especially in psychology. Its use in common parlace, as in moronic behaviour, is both common and widely accepted.
Regarding places being evil, you are technically correct: no place is of itself evil. But places can be associated with great evil as in Dachau or Treblinka. Why were the homes of Fred and Rosemary West and Josef Fritzl razed?
Michael

Michael Commane said...

The Michael of the above comment should not be confused with the Michael of this entry.

Collins English Dictionary gives two meanings for 'moron'. The first entry says the word means a foolish or stupid person.

And on places: a wise Dominican once siad that the walls of San Clemente carried 'the stuff' that made it the place it was

Delighted people are reading this blog. It's now read on all continents in 140 cities around the world.

Póló said...

@Michael Commane

Perhaps you could give us details of the premises which has not erased the graffiti and we could reinforce your appeal.

I have been to Dachau, which I know was not the worst camp, but it was, and still is, very disturbing. That was around 1979.

Regarding moron. The place is, unfortunately, full of them, and if we get any more PC appeals to lay off the word we will have nothing forceful enough to describe them. Stupid people? Tut, tut!

.

Featured Post

A personal request

I would be grateful if Sean, who made a comment on this blog about the late Paddy Cullen, contact me. Is it possible to have your email addr...