Tuesday, January 31, 2023

The Beatitudes and capitalism don’t mix

This week’s Independent News & Media Irish regionals newspapers’ column.

Michael Commane

James O’Brien presents a programme on UK’s LBC radio station every weekday from 10 am to midday. 


He has links with Ireland and born a Catholic, which he often mentions on his radio programme. He was educated at the Benedictine-run Ampleforth  College, in other words he comes from privilege.


After school he studied Economics and Philosophy. O’Brien has a background in journalism, has worked for a number of UK newspapers and has presented BBC 2’s Newsnight. I’ve been listening to him on Mondays now for a number of weeks. He is critical of the governing class in the UK and strongly objects to a society that cannot pay its nurses a decent wage, which at the same time has no issues with a small number of individuals being paid obscene sums of money.


Listening to him these days I’m reminded of former archbishop of San Salvador, Oscar Romero, who was murdered celebrating Mass in 1980. 


Romero had an interesting take on last Sunday’s Gospel, which was St Matthew’s account of the Beatitudes. He said: ‘Even when they call us mad, when they call us subversives and communists and all the epithets they put on us, we know we only preach the subversive witness of the Beatitudes, which have turned everything upside down.’ 


The Beatitudes are what we would call today the mission statement of Christianity. Jesus supports the poor, the gentle, ‘happy the peacemakers: they shall be called children of God’.


Listening to O’Brien and reading what Romero had to say about the Beatitudes I can’t help thinking that there is something profoundly wrong with how we are managing the world’s resources. In January aid agency Oxfam published a report outlining how the rich are getting richer and the poor poorer.


In the last two years the richest one per cent have acquired almost twice as much wealth as the remaining 99 per cent of the world’s population. 800 million people in the world have not enough to eat. 


In Ireland the richest one per cent have 27 per cent of wealth. 1,435 Irish people own over €46.6  million each. This number has more than doubled in 10 years. Surely it is an indictment of our imbalanced economic system that a few can accumulate such wealth while thousands struggle to put food on the table and keep a roof over their heads. Does it make sense that a CEO of an Irish company should be paid €9.3 million in one year? Elon Musk’s net worth works out at €140.85 billion, Jeff Bezos has €110.84 bn  and Mark Zuckerberg has amassed €46.41 billion. 


I can hear people say they have earned that money and are entitled to it. I can hear others say that many of them do great good with their wealth. All fine and dandy but what about the 800 million who have not enough to eat, is that their fault? Houston we have a problem and we need to do something about it.


Take the current war in Ukraine, the real winner is the armaments’ industry. Have we ever allowed the Beatitudes to turn ‘everything upside down’?

Monday, January 30, 2023

How far away is schism in the Catholic Church?

Rite and Reason column in The Irish Times on January 23. Well worth a read.

https://www.irishtimes.com/opinion/2023/01/23/ritereason-i-have-gone-off-christians-these-days/

A terrible wrong committed by Britain in Ireland 51 years ago

 On this day, January 30, 1972 the British Army in Northern Ireland opened fire on a peaceful anti-internment demonstration in Derry murdering 14 people.

It took many decades for the London government to recognise the wrong they did on that Sunday in Derry 51 years ago.

A terrible wrong committed by Britain in Ireland

On this day, January 30, 1972 the British Army in Northern Ireland opened fire on a peaceful anti-internment demonstration in Derry murdering 14 people.

It took many decades for the London government to recognise the wrong they did on that Sunday in Derry 51 years ago.



Sunday, January 29, 2023

The Holocaust can never be forgotten

Each day German police log five anti-Semitic attacks on people and Jewish buildings, which are guarded around the clock.

50,000 men were convicted in Germany between 1933 and 1945 for homosexual acts and any ‘lewd act’.

In that same period approximately 10,000 convicted homosexual men were sent to German death camps, where they were forced to wear a pink triangle, the lowest rung of the  prisoner hierarchy.

In the last two weeks Russian President Vladimir Putin spoke about homosexuality as an abomination and new laws are being introduced in the Russian Federation outlawing ‘lewd behaviour’.

Iranian law strictly forbids homosexuality.

Dutch woman Rozette, whose parents were murdered in Auschwitz, said on Friday at a Holocaust memorial service in Berlin: “If people are divided into categories of more or less value, it means that the Nazi ideology lives on and remains effective.” 

In recent days Pope Francis has been quoted as saying that homosexual activity should not be a civil offence.


Saturday, January 28, 2023

The Beatitudes are a mission statement about subversion

The Thinking Anew column in The Irish Times today.

Michael Commane

Tomorrow’s Gospel (Mt 5: 1 - 12) is Matthew’s account of the Beatitudes, the opening section of the Sermon on the Mount. In modern parlance it is a mission statement of what Christianity is about.

Before sitting down to write this column I asked a number of people what the Beatitudes meant to them. I got as many replies as people I asked. A medical doctor sent me a piece titled ‘Beatitudes for Caregivers’, which included these words: “Blessed are those who, when nothing can be done or said, do not walk away, but remain to provide a comforting and supportive presence — they will help the sufferer to bear the unbearable.”


Someone else said that they have to be read as a unit and it made little sense to concentrate on any one of them at the expense of the others.

 

The Beatitudes are about a way of life, a life that is good and wholesome and unfolds God to us, and one where we in turn make ourselves available to God.


In the first reading in tomorrow’s liturgy the prophet Zephaniah  (2: 3, 3: 12 - 13) suggests that we seek the Lord, we who are “the humble of the earth”. The Psalmist (Psalm 145) tells us that it is the Lord who keeps faith for ever.


But how do we go about seeking the Lord? 


Oscar Romero, archbishop of San Salvador, who flew the flag for the downtrodden and poor and who was eventually murdered for his outspoken views on injustice, has an interesting take on the Beatitudes: "Even  when they call us mad, when they call us subversives and communists and all the epithets they put on us, we know we only preach the subversive witness of the Beatitudes, which have turned everything upside down.”


I find it interesting that Romero uses the word subversive, indeed uses it twice. He obviously saw the Beatitudes as a way of life recognising  that if they were to mean anything they would upset the status quo. And that’s so strange because before being appointed archbishop of San Salvador he was considered a socially conservative man. 


Last week aid agency Oxfam published a report outlining how the rich are getting richer and the poor poorer. In the last two years the richest one per cent have acquired almost twice as much wealth as the remaining 99 per cent of the world’s population. 800 million people in the world have not enough to eat.


In Ireland the richest one per cent have 27 per cent of wealth. 1,435 Irish people own over €46.6  million each. This number has more than doubled in 10 years. The richest one per cent have gained 70 times more wealth than the poorest 50 per cent in 10 years. 


These are worrying statistics. It is an indictment of our imbalanced economic system that a few can accumulate such wealth while thousands struggle to put food on the table and keep a roof over their heads.

 

Does it mean that if someone stands up and objects to the current status quo they are subversive? 


Archbishop Oscar Romero  never walked away from those who suffered. He was canonised by Pope Francis in 2018.


Is it possible to appreciate the value of the Beatitudes without taking into account the Romero factor? I doubt it. Christianity is about communion, and one might well ask if we have lost our focus on the real meaning of breaking bread with our fellow sisters and brothers.


Jesus told the crowds listening to him that they should be happy “… when people abuse you and persecute you and speak all kinds of calumny against you on my account”.


Jesus had little or no time for the status quo. Obviously, Oscar Romero took his cue from Jesus. The Gospels are inspirational. They remind us that the Lord keeps faith in us for ever. 


He is the one in whom we find freedom and protection, completely outside and removed  from the status quo.


Instead of being in awe of the “gospel of wealth” wouldn’t it be far better to take a leaf out of Oscar Romero’s interpretation of the Beatitudes, and for us to be inspired by the Gospel of Jesus Christ? 


Friday, January 27, 2023

The intricacies of German Russian relations

Today is International Holocaust Day.

The Germans murdered six million people in their death camps.

The Soviet Union lost over 20 million people as the result of German aggression.

On this day, January 27, 1945 the Soviet Army liberated the German death camp at Auschwitz-Birkenau. 

It was the Soviet 322nd Rifle Division who arrived at the gates of Auschwitz. 

They later scored military victories against the Germans in western Ukraine and in Poland and were part of the Red Army that moved on to liberate Berlin.

Another Soviet victory was the lifting of the 900-day siege of Leningrad on January 27, 1944.

Mother Russia has suffered too much, lost too many people as has Ukraine, whose people were starved to death under the Staline regime. 

Where is the United Nations? What’s its purpose if it is not to foster peace?

The story of Yevgeny Prigozhin according to the Guardian

The story of Yevgeny Prigozhin, the man who grew up in the same city as President Vladimir Putin and now runs an alternative army to the Russian Army. 

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/24/yevgeny-prigozhin-the-hotdog-seller-who-rose-to-the-top-of-putin-war-machine-wagner-group?CMP=share_btn_link

Thursday, January 26, 2023

Scholz gives the green light to the Leopard battle tank

It has been decided that German tanks are once again to roll over the land of Ukraine. This time they will be accompanied by US Abrams and UK Challengers. Along with the German Leopard, all three vehicles are heavy battle tanks. There are 2.000 German built Leopard tank across Europe.

No one knows how this war is going to go. Russia has to be stopped. But should Nato have gone right up to the door of Russia?

It’s most unlikely that Russia will leave Crimea. What happens if Putin is humiliated?

On Russian television yesterday a commentator said that the Fourth Reich had arrived and that Berlin was now a legitimate target.

Friday is International Holocaust Day.

The piece below is from the Guardian.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/25/scholzs-caution-over-tanks-for-ukraine-echoed-on-berlin-streets?CMP=share_btn_link

Wednesday, January 25, 2023

The ever escalating war in Ukraine a cause of great concern

Today the Germans will give the green light to send the Leopard ll battle tank to Ukraine. Most likely the US will send their Abram battle tanks to Ukraine

Where will all this stop?

Russia under Vladimir Putin will not be deterred by this latest escalation. And it seems we have been lulled into believing that the war is ‘over there’ and not our problem.

It is a global problem.

Where are the peacemakers we shall read about in next Sunday’s Gospel?


Tuesday, January 24, 2023

High wind and hailstones won the day on Djouce

This week’s Independent News & Media/Mediahuis Irish regional newspapers’ column.


Michael Commane

If I remember correctly, the weather forecast  for Saturday January 14 was ok. There was a small chance of rain and yes the previous days had been quite windy. The winds had died down but there was still some wind blowing.


Myself and two friends decided we’d go walking in the Wicklow Hills. They are far more accomplished walkers than I, which means I always leave it to them to decide where we’ll go. 


They are also significantly younger than I, indeed, I taught one of them in secondary school and then worked with him later, and the other walker and I began working in a newspaper on the same day fadó fadó.


It was decided we’d climb Djouce, which rises to 725 metres. It’s north of Roundwood, south west of Kilcamacanoge. It is situated along the 131- kilometre Wicklow Way. It’s a walk we have often done. We planned to go walking for between three and four hours.


The ground was quite wet, no rain but it was colder than I had expected. Close to an hour’s walking uphill there was a significant increase in the wind, the clouds darkened and it began to hailstone. Within a short period of time it became positively dangerous. I was having difficulty standing and the strength of the hailstones against my face was anything but pleasant. 


With difficulty we stopped to put on rain gear. We continued walking for about 10, 15 minutes. The three of us decided it was time to abort. It was a unanimous decision. We headed down the valley, retracing our steps. 


En route we stopped for a bite to eat and took shelter behind a stone wall. At this stage the rain had cleared, the dark clouds were gone and we could see out over to Dalkey. It was as if a light was shining down on Dublin Bay. It’s very seldom we have had to abandon a walk. It happened I remember once, and that was because I was simply not able to continue. My two companions are far stronger and tougher than I, younger too, as I said.


With my back to the wall, a flask of water in one hand and a sandwich in the other I was struck with the beauty of the place. But there was a word that suddenly began to ring in my head, failure. 


Had we failed? We planned to get to the top of Djouce. We didn’t get there, so yes, we failed. We decided it could have been dangerous to continue and also it would have been torturous.


Since that walk I’ve been thinking of the word failure and what it means to fail. Indeed, it’s a word and an idea that actually haunts me. I’m often reminded of that famous comment from the English politician Enoch Powell, who said that all politics ends in failure. I often whisper to myself that all life ends in failure.


That can’t be, nor is it. Our walk that day was not a failure. It was a lovely day out, good company and a nice mix of weather conditions.


I’m wondering do we put far too much emphasis on failure. It is simply awful to call someone a loser. I hate to hear people use that word.


Maybe that’s what resurrection is all about; success always triumphs over failure. I hope it does.

Monday, January 23, 2023

The pupil who was tongue-tied when it came to monsignor

This little story appears in the current issue of The Irish Catholic. It appears in the column written by Fr Martin Delaney.

Whatever about knowing what a pectoral cross is, who might know what a monsignor is. What is a monsignor, a title about what? What are all these clerical titles about?

How would it be possible to explain the title of monsignor to a child, indeed, to anyone?

Sunday, January 22, 2023

As Ukraine fights Russia, Germany is fighting with itself

While the West, Nato and Germany dither about sending the Leopard 2 battle tank to Ukraine, once the US entered World War ll they produced a battle tank every five minutes.

But it is understandable why Germany is slow to dispatch the Leopard to Ukrainian soil. Eighty one years ago Germany unleashed a bloodbath in Ukraine and were the cause of 20 million Russians losing their lives. And there is also the logic that when this war is over Germany will want to rebuild relations with Russia.

Olaf Scholz keeps stressing that Germany wants to do no solo-run in Ukraine. That makes sense, knowing the history of Germany and the Soviet Union.

As Derek Scally writes in The Irish Times yesterday: "As Ukraine fights Russia, Germany is fighting with itself. Being forced beyond its postwar comfort zone is an open-ended experiment. As Scholz remarked a year ago: 'Whether we have it in us to keep warmongers like Putin in check requires strength of our own.’ "

Saturday, January 21, 2023

Old Jury’s would be ideal for housing refugees

 Justine McCarthy's opinion piece in The Irish Times yesterday makes for a good read.

Why is the old Jury’s Hotel in Ballsbridge not being used to house Ukrainians and other refugees?


The principle of continuing to accept refugees and asylum seekers is commendable. The problem lies with the policy’s implementation

Once it was the totem pole of the Celtic Tiger where bedraggled debutantes ate breakfast at dawn and Seán Dunne, the era’s most ostentatious developer, proposed building a diamond-shaped skyscraper. Now the old Jurys hotel in Dublin 4 is a padlocked Sodom and Gomorrah. The lights went out about three years ago. A security company’s notices on the perimeter warn against trespass and all that is missing is the tumbleweed. As evening rush-hour traffic inched past its gates last week, the morality soap opera encapsulated by the former hotel took a new and disconcerting twist.

Homeward-bound in their bumper-to-bumper cars, many commuters would have been listening to live radio coverage of a protest that was under way outside the Travelodge hotel in Ballymun, where some asylum seekers are residing temporarily. Much of what was said was vile. One demonstrator complained that “men of military age” were staying there without “Garda vetting” and that mothers were terrified for their children’s safety. Her words echoed the horrible presumption of criminal guilt being recited at other protests taking place simultaneously in various parts of Dublin. The reporter listed the locations as Drimnagh, East Wall and Clondalkin. Tallaght, Finglas and Ballyfermot have had their share of demonstrations too.

An asylum applicant who gave his name as Ahmed, talked about the fear inside the hotel, where women and children who have endured unthinkable vicissitudes were listening to chants of “get them out”. The protester denied racism was the objectors’ motivation, and claimed to be taking the action “for Ireland and the Irish people”.

Not in my name, many listeners might have thought, and rightly so. But how many motorists idling in the Ballsbridge traffic looked at the decanted Jurys hotel and thought “hold on a minute, there’s something not right here – why are the 404 en-suite bedrooms in there not being used for emergency occupation?”

The Dublin districts where protests are becoming regular events have a common denominator. They are what were traditionally called working class areas. Certainly none is as salubrious as Dublin 4, Ireland’s redbrick citadel of wealth. Its verdant roads are home to some of the country’s richest individuals and most of its embassies, as well as a disproportionate number of four- and five-star hotels and private schools. Yet Ballsbridge and similar Dublin enclaves of privilege do not house large numbers of people seeking asylum. Until you shoulder some of the responsibility do you even have a right to say “not in my name”?

The old Jurys, which Dunne bought in 2005 for €240 million, thus fuelling the property bubble that helped collapse the Irish economy three years later, would make an ideal location for refugees. There is a bus stop right outside the front gate, a Dart station behind it and the city centre is just a 15-minute walk away.

The property comprises double, twin and family rooms, bedroom suites, kitchens, 12 meeting rooms, a restaurant, a bar and a hair salon, all now defunct. After Dunne went bankrupt his lender, Ulster Bank, sold the place to Chartered Land, another property developer, which has agreed to reconstruct it as the new headquarters for the US embassy. According to media reports, it may be the best part of a decade before the embassy can move in.

Last year local Labour Party city councillor Dermot Lacey mooted that the hotel be used to accommodate Ukrainian refugees on a short-term basis. He argued that, as it had been functioning until relatively recently, the building should not require extensive refurbishment, but a spokesperson for Chartered Land said it was uninhabitable, and so the lights have stayed off.

Meanwhile, residents in Tallaght, where Dublin Bus has restricted services following attacks on its drivers, and in Ballymun, where the sole shopping centre was demolished two years ago, and in East Wall, which has been blighted by organised killings, are expected to put up and shut up. When resentment that has built up over decades of social deprivation in these areas erupts and is directed at people who have fled their own countries for their lives and their livelihoods, Official Ireland, comfortably ensconced in the leafy suburbs, tut-tuts with disapproval.

This double standard provides a fertile breeding ground for xenophobic provocateurs such as those on the far-right who have been mustering the protests. The current Government – and particularly Fine Gael, which has been in power for 12 consecutive years – has failed catastrophically to ensure that citizens can have homes. However, its commitment to continue receiving Ukrainian refugees and asylum seekers from other countries is commendable.

Humanitarian record

The principle chimes with Ireland’s humanitarian record, the history of the Irish diaspora and a republic’s idealism. Where it errs is in the implementation. Yes, there are big numbers of people arriving on Ireland’s shores, and, yes, the demands on accommodation are formidable, and, yes, agitators with pernicious agendas are exploiting the situation, but the situation was not created by them.

To their immense credit many people in the areas where protests have been taking place have mounted counterprotests to demonstrate their revulsion at the hostile reception being given to those in refugee accommodation. If those areas have one advantage over affluent gated suburbs it is the strength of their community spirit.

What they do not have is the wherewithal to make public protests unnecessary by engaging lawyers and taking their case to the High Court, as did a residents’ association on Pembroke Road, where Jurys stands, when they obtained an order stopping the State using a guesthouse in their midst as a reception centre for asylum seekers in 2000. A member of the residents’ association had argued that the area was “becoming saturated with unwanted elements who are a threat to the settled community”. There were no media reports of politicians denouncing the objectors as racists.

The hatred being shown by small numbers towards refugees and asylum seekers is stomach-churning but so too is the discrimination against non-privileged communities that underlies the provision of accommodation. Official Ireland revels in its self-image as egalitarian, frequently quoting taxation data as proof. But there are as many ways of measuring equality as there are euphemisms in the dictionary for apartheid.


Friday, January 20, 2023

A church in London that takes its lead from God

This mission statement is posted outside St Paul’s Church, West Hackney, London  

WELCOME TO ST PAUL'S WEST HACKNEY

We are a community of folk who are single, married, partnered, divorced, widowed, lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, cisgender, intersex, gender fluid, not quite sure, rich, poor and penniless.

Some of us are wailing babies and are others excited toddlers. Some of us are a bit north of 60 and haven't quite grown up and some of us are in our teens and often feel like we’re growing up too fast. We are wheelchair users, runners, walkers and amblers. Sometimes we stumble and fall and when we do, we try and help each other up again.

Some of us sing like Mel Tormé whilst others of us are happy just to growl quietly to ourselves. Some of us have come to browse, some have just woken up and some have just been released from prison.

Some of us attend church more than the Archbishop of Canterbury and some of us haven’t darkened the doors of a church since we were on the way home from that Christmas party ten years ago. Some of us are here because our mother is visiting for the weekend and it's more than our lives are worth not to go to church with her and look as though we’re having something that bears a passing resemblance to a good time.

Some of us find the whole idea of God a bit odd, have been damaged by religion, were force-fed religion as children or have wound up here by mistake. Some of us could use a prayer right now, have screwed up monumentally and would like to light a candle but don't quite know why or to whom. A goodly number of us aren’t what you might call ‘exactly struck’ on organised religion.

Some of us are inked, pierced or both. Some are in recovery and others are still addicted. Some of us work too hard, some don't work, can't work, can't spell and feel like we’re not very good at stuff, when in fact we almost certainly are. Most of us know what it’s like to have problems, to be down in the dumps and, on occasions, to feel angry with God.

Most of us have figured out that you can never really know what’s right for another person and some of us long for some stillness in an often-noisy world, where we can discover the treasure that is within us.

We are a mixture of pilgrims, tourists, migrants, asylum seekers, neighbours, explorers, doubters and those who prefer to travel rather than to arrive. We call ourselves and each other to go about life in as compassionate, generous, collaborative, loving, creative, hospitable and grateful a way as possible.

We believe that the God who called us all into being - however he, she or they may be perceived – welcomes, embraces and loves us all. 

We at St Paul's try, in our own stumbling way, to take our lead from God as we go about welcoming, embracing and loving ourselves and one another.

Thursday, January 19, 2023

Inspiring words from Oscar Romero

"Even  when they call us mad, when they call us subversives and communists and all the epithets they put on us, we know we only preach the subversive witness to the Beatitudes, which have turned everything upside down."


- Oscar Romero

Wednesday, January 18, 2023

Chancellor Scholz names Germany’s new defence minister

Yesterday Boris Pistorious was named as Germany’s new defence minister. Up to now he has been the interior minister in the State of Lower Saxony. It comes as a surprise decision.

On Thursday US defence secretary Lloyd Austin will be in Germany. The Germans have to decide whether or not to deliver their Leopard battle tank to Ukraine.

The opposition CDU believes that the Scholz government is far too slow in coming to the support of Ukraine.

Coalition partners The Green Party and the FDP have expressed their willingness to deliver the Leopard tank to Ukraine.

People criticise Chancellor Scholz for his hesitancy in supporting the war in Ukraine. But it is understandable that a German chancellor would be slow to send heavy tanks to Ukraine. It must be a nightmare  for any German chancellor to think of a scenario where German tanks face down Russian tanks on Ukrainian soil.

We are living in extremely dangerous times.

German history is so intertwined in its past. To add to the intrigue of it all the new defence minister Pistorious was in a relationship with Doris Schröder-Köpf from 2016 to 2022. She is a former wife of the now discredited chancellor Gerhard Schröder, who is a personal friend of Vladimir Putin.

And on a historical note, on this day in 1945 the Polish city of Krakow was liberated by the Red Army.

The war in Ukraine is the result of Putin’s aggression but Putin knows the buttons to push.

Yesterday CDU leader, Friedrich Merz said that the defence minister next to the chancellor is the most important person in the German cabinet.

Until the war in Ukraine most German politicians spoke about the German army, airforce and navy in whispers. The monster ghost of the Wehrmacht is never too far away.

Germany will be forever haunted by what the Wehrmacht did, but especially what it did in Ukraine.

It’s not too often spoken of but Germany, after the US, is the second largest contributor to the Ukrainian war effort.



Tuesday, January 17, 2023

The NTA misses the bus for rural Ireland

This week’s Independent News & Media/Mediahuis Irish regional newspapers’ column.


Michael Commane

I am constantly intrigued by how we as a nation organise our public transport system.

 

Some months ago I explained how flabbergasted I was to discover that the new single decker buses currently being rolled out across rural Ireland do not take bicycles, not even fold-ups. I was painfully reminded of this after Christmas when I was travelling from Tralee to Camp in West Kerry.


Fortunately I had a bicycle bag for my fold-up, which meant I was allowed carry the bicycle on board with me. 


There are no words to explain that the State has bought a fleet of buses to travel to the most scenic areas in the country that do not have the capacity to carry bicycles. I mentioned it on one occasion to a driver. He looked at me and said: ‘That’s Dublin for you. They make all the decisions and they have not got a clue.’

 

We all know the vital importance the role public transport must play if we are to clean up our act. 

Dublin Bus has now a significant number of hybrid electric vehicles in its fleet. It is planning to roll out all electric buses later this year. And Bus Éireann is operating a small number of hydrogen buses.


We are making progress but as we do, the confusion grows.


In 1987 Córas Iompair Éireann (CIÉ) was split into three new entities, Dublin Bus, Iarnród Éireann and Bus Éireann, with CIÉ becoming the holding company for all three companies. But two new entities have now been created. They are the NTA - National Transport Authority and TFI - Transport for Ireland.


When I went to ask or complain about not being able to take even a fold-up bicycle on one of the new rural buses I was told that I should make my complaint to NTA. 


The gentleman with whom I spoke clearly explained to me that Bus Éireann was no longer in the picture when it came to decision making. Of course the design of the bus did not allow for bicycles. He went on to point out that Bus Éireann has been contracted to run the service under an NTA licence for a specific number of years and that Bus Éireann or CIÉ had no say in the purchase of the vehicles. He also told me that the time tables are no longer the remit of Bus Éireann.


He then tried to explain to me the role TFI is playing in the overall transport project. When I asked him what was the difference between the role of the NTA and TFI I became confused. To tell you the truth, I got the distinct impression that he too was lost.


Google tells me that National Transport Authority is the transport authority for Greater Dublin and the public transport licensing agency for Ireland. And I discovered that Transport for Ireland is the public brand of the National Transport Authority.

Is this just all quango speech?

 

I have no idea what it’s all about but I do know the new rural buses are not fit for purpose. Next time you travel on one look for the phone charger. A driver kindly told me there was one and that was under a seat. I eventually found it. Imagine placing a charger socket in a place where it cannot be seen. You couldn’t make it up. 


Who made the decision to buy these buses? 

Sunday, January 15, 2023

Failure? Whatever it was, it was a fabulous adventure

Three of us set out yesterday for Djouce

(725 metres) in the Wicklow Hills. 

There were blue skies over Dublin in the morning and no sign of any rain. The forecast was for rain clearing and temperatures to drop, wind too was suggested.

We headed out from the car park, which is approximately a 20-minute drive from Kilmacanoge. The car park is near the Dargle River.

Underfoot it was wet. An hour into our walk and at close to 550 metres the wind was rising. Every few metres meant a significant increase in wind speeds, then the darkening skies and a torrential shower of hailstones. Those stones hit hard against the face and all the while the wind was getting stronger and stronger. It became difficult to stand upright. 

We made a decision to abort, head back down into the valley and make for the car park. One of the first times ever on a mountain walk that we decided to turn back. Failure? Maybe. But whatever one might call it it was a fabulous Saturday afternoon.

On the way down we took shelter beside a stone wall, ate bread and cheese, and drank water. At this stage the sky had cleared. Beautiful scenes, we could see out over to Dalkey.

A fabulous Saturday afternoon.

Saturday, January 14, 2023

German Leopard tanks on the 'side of good' in Ukraine

 Oleksiy Danilov, secretary of Ukraine’s national security and defence council, said on Thursday: “German Leopard tanks on the Ukrainian steppes in 2023 on the ‘side of good’ have a chance to balance the historical scales of justice, which were shaken by the evil of Wehrmacht tanks in the 1940s.”

A valid point. But it might also play into the hands of President Putin to argue that once again German tanks roll on Ukrainian soil, attacking Russian tanks. 

Putin can easily tell the Russian people this is The Great Patriotic War Mark II.


Friday, January 13, 2023

A red light means nothing else than stop

Far too many vehicles pass traffic lights when there are showing red. 

Does the RSA or the Department of Transport have any statistics on the subject.

It’s time cameras were installed at traffic lights to help deter drivers from going through red lights.

Cyclists too far too often break the lights but it ids far more dangerous when cars and trucks commit the offence.

It’s well worth noting how often it happens. Just take one day and observe what happens at traffic lights.

Thursday, January 12, 2023

Dominicans leave Neustadt-am-Main in Germany’s Spessart

On Monday, January 9 the Dominican Sisters of the Oakford Congregation closed the doors of their convent in Neustadt-am-Main and moved to a residence in nearby Kist.

Dominican Sisters had been in Neustadt since the beginning of the 20th century and in the 1970s they built a rehabilitation centre which they successfully ran for many years.

All over the Western World religious congregations are closing their doors, fewer women and men are joining congregations. Numbers of young men joining priesthood shrink by the day. Because of the declining numbers of priests, bishops muddle about trying to organise some sort of framework so as to keep parishes afloat. The new magic word is ‘cluster’. It’s appeared and does anyone really know what hit means. Jargon?

Over the last 50 years has there ever been any real, honest, open discussion as what the future holds. Has anyone had the courage to say out loud there can be no taboo subjects?

It seems as if it has all been controlled by a group of people, who are far distant from the pulse of the women and men who are in actual fact the church. It might well be fair to ask has the church been hijacked by a clerical caste?

Wednesday, January 11, 2023

Post-holiday bins a metaphor for disposable society

The article below, written by Gerard Howlin, appeared in The Irish Times yesterday.

What is out of sight is out of mind. The debris of our pagan festival has been taken away. Excess has been sanitised and houses emptied of the carcasses and packaging we consumed and then discarded. 

Domestic order is restored, but the consequences of what we have done if just out of sight remains nearby. 

The fuller impact is global, accumulating and permanent.

Christmas is a metaphor for a disposable society. It’s a bumper crop of oblivion. It is also seamless continuity of how we live now. We are a single-use society. The disposable cup that hosts our coffee culture is a flagship for discordance between an imagined latte lifestyle and the unspeakable squalor it is anchored to.

In 2018 we threw out about 200 million cups. Fast fashion that depends on cheap sweat, globalised supply lines and packaging to boot can’t withstand us sweating inside it. It is allergic to washing, and must be quickly replaced. Our sophisticated gizmos from the humble kettle to the cinema screen-sized television are immune to repair. They are purposely designed for throwaway.

There is something called a linear economy and then there is a circular economy. We are world leaders in linear. It is not that our per capita outputs of waste are world-beating. It is that we have perfected a lifestyle that maximises our capacity to party, minimises our personal exposure to the consequences and has just enough of the balm of action to allow us have a very good time and feel good about ourselves at the same time. It is psychologically a sweet spot, and explains how after good progress on recycling over several years we have plateaued since.

The progress achieved means the low-hanging fruit is eaten. We are down from over 100 licensed landfill sites to just two. Waste segregation at home is both an essential thing and a false panacea. It leads to a sense that we have done our thing.

Waste recycling
In fact municipal waste recycling has increased by 11 per cent since 2016, but total waste generated also increased by 11 per cent, so the recycling rate has stagnated at 41 per cent. On a personal level we are doing a little better on how we deal with our consumer effluent but all the while we are creating ever more of it. We have hardly started on the circular economy.

Recycling is only the beginning. Reuse and reduction are the bigger challenges we have hardly addressed. This is where popular culture and personal choice meet global warming. The linear economy requires continuing exploitation, manufacture, transport and packaging of new raw materials globally to supply insatiable need. 

Consumption is the prelude to disposal. There is only an instant between peak presentation and packaging before use disintegrates what had been must-have into takeaway.

On Sunday it was reported that England will follow Scotland and Wales and ban single-use items such as plastic cutlery, plates and trays. The simple plastic fork has a 200-year lifespan.

There are other simple choices to hand. The maligned Brussels sprout was provided by nature with its own packaging. So was the banana, the apple and orange. Environmental awareness goes when we go shopping. Why do potatoes need plastic packaging?

Design stage
The bigger issue is design. Most waste is built in at design stage.

That’s where EU and national legislation comes in. The humble cotton bud is no longer stuck on a plastic stick. Legislation forced design change. Circular economy legislation here since last summer and pending EU legislation will significantly extend powers over design. The Government can now ban stuff and will begin to do so. 

The disposable vape must be a particularly vile example of avoidable waste.

A key pressure on design is extended consumer responsibility (ECR). That makes manufacturers responsible for the afterlife of their products and incentivises waste-reduction and designs out what is unnecessary or can’t be reused. 

That is important because 80 per cent of environmental impacts are baked in at design stage. There has been a change in fashion about where responsibility lies. The emphasis on personal responsibility has switched to industry. That has certainly been a convenient cop-out for national politicians, who belly ache about climate levies and charges. It supposedly champions so called ordinary people but in reality it infantilises them.

It is our desire to spend more time with our stuff that is driving consumption up. We segregate waste to feel good, but actually we do it badly. Our bin contamination rates are appalling. Barely 2 per cent of our stuff comes from material that is recycled or recovered. 

All else comes from the exploitation of new primary raw material globally.


Tuesday, January 10, 2023

Are the churches fit for purpose today?

This week’s Independent New & Media/Mediahuis Irish regional newspapers’ column.

Michael Commane

The king is dead, long live the king. In this instance we can’t quite say the pope is dead, long live the pope. Pope Emeritus Benedict resigned in 2013. 

He was no longer pope at his death. I believe this is the first time in the history of the church that a pope presided over the funeral Mass of another pope.

Who was Pope Benedict, aka Jospeh Ratzinger? What sort of a man was he? I suppose only his close friends could answer that question. 


The world agrees that he was a fine academic, a top class thinker. I know someone who casually met him one day in Rome, they spent ten minutes talking and my friend found him most personable and friendly, indeed Ratzinger that same day told a work colleague he had met an impressive Irish man.


While in his job as prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith he was known by some as a Rottweiler, in other words he had the touch of being a tough disciplinarian, who came down heavily on any sort of what some might call questionable theological writing. 


It was he who gave the final say on the current missal we use in Ireland at Mass. In my opinion it has not in any way helped us pray any better and it has been a colossal waste of money. It’s interesting that Germany never revised their missal.


Has the German pope done more to unite or divide the Catholic Church? Did Ratzinger simply carry on the baton that was given him by John Paul II?


I heard a priest of the Dublin archdiocese say that  he feels that the Catholic Church is heading for schism and only last week a fellow Dominican expressed his opinion that the church is currently in free fall. Strong words.


When I read some of the commentary on Pope Emeritus Benedict after his death I was bemused. The usual suspects said what was expected of them. 


But isn’t that always the way it is when a world or well-known figure dies? When Leonid Brezhnev died the Communist world wrote in great praise of him, just as the western world eulogised on JFK when he was shot dead in Dallas.


The world is a strange place. Life is a mystery and death is weird. But right now across Europe no one could say that Christian churches are in a healthy place and certainly from my long association with the Catholic Church I have no difficulty in saying matters are grim.


Is the institutional church, governed by a hierarchical system, fit for purpose today? Why are so many good and honest people, young and old, not paying any heed to the church? I keep getting the impression that priesthood is broken. 


Yes, there are small cliques that hold together but is there today any genuine real friendship or honesty among priests? I think it is all breaking down and there is deep distrust among priests, fear too. What about kindness?


I hope the words of poet and philosopher John O’Donoghue can take hold for all of us: ‘Awaken your spirit to adventure;/ Hold nothing back, learn to find ease in risk;/ Soon you will be home in a new rhythm/ For your soul senses the world that awaits you.’

Monday, January 9, 2023

The story of the two bags of manure and the RTÉ interview

At a public meeting in Gort in County Galway a farmer attending the meeting threw two bags of animal excrement at Fianna Fáil junior minister Anne Rabbit and Fine Gael back bencher Ciaran Cannon.

On Friday’s Joe Duffy Show, Katie Hannon, who was standing in for Joe Duffy, interviewed the offending farming. Is it not unusual to interview on national radio a person who behaves in such a manner?

And then on Sunday the subject was discussed on the Brendan O’Connor Show. When some of the panellists were about to make a comment on the behaviour of the farmer who threw the two bags Brendan immediately ended the discussion. It seems as if he was not willing to hear one negative comment about the farmer.

It is of course the job of the Garda to follow up on an alleged crime and the courts to decide if the person is guilty of a crime. 

Would RTÉ interview a person who had the possibility of being arrested for a wrong doing? Doubtful.

Throw bags of manure at TDs seems to be one way of appearing on RTÉ. Odd.

Sunday, January 8, 2023

Ratzinger was torn between different versions of himself

This from the current issue of The Tablet. 

The idea that Ratzinger was always torn between different versions of himself surely is a stand out:

The dome of St Peter’s basilica was covered with mist as the first mourners entered the square this morning, among them a Bavarian marching band from Pope Benedict’s homeland noisily making their way into the piazza. Pope Francis arrived in a wheelchair shortly before 9.30 am to preside at the funeral of his predecessor. 

Christopher Lamb watched as he was vested at the altar while 125 cardinals processed into the square. In his homily, read while sitting before the altar, Francis said that Benedict had “spread and testified to” the Gospel for his “entire life”, in the face of “challenges and resistance”, a nod perhaps to the turbulence that often surrounded his eight-year papacy and his 24 years as head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. 


Saturday, January 7, 2023

Inspirational words spoken at Kevin Lyon’s funeral Mass

The funeral Mass of Archdeacon Kevin Lyon took place in Blessington parish church last Wednesday.

Fr Tim Murphy presided and preached at the Mass. His words after the Gospel were powerful, inspirational.

The sermon is available on the Blessington parish website. Below is the link.

Funeral Mass for Archdeacon Kevin Lyon RIP 04 Jan 10_20

Friday, January 6, 2023

Putin’s ceasefire is a religious travesty

The below text is published on the Kremlin website and addressed to defence minister Shoigu.

What does it say about religion, or at least the Russian president’s understanding of religion, or indeed Patriarch Kirill’s faith?

Is it ok to kill, plunder, burn, rape on the other days of the year?

Anyway, ceasefires take place in wars and not ‘Special Military Operations’.

“Taking into account the appeal of his holiness Patriarch Kirill, I instruct the minister of defence of the Russian Federation to introduce a ceasefire regime along the entire line of contact of the parties in Ukraine in from 12.00 on 6 January 2023 to 24.00 on 7 January 2023,” 

“Based on the fact that a large number of citizens professing Orthodoxy live in the areas of hostilities, we call on the Ukrainian side to declare a ceasefire and allow them to attend services on Christmas Eve, as well as on Christmas Day,” Putin added.

Thursday, January 5, 2023

The German priest who became pope is buried today

On this the day the funeral Mass of Joseph Ratzinger/ Pope Benedict takes place, the link to an interview with Australian theologian Tracey Rowland is an appropriate read.

Ratzinger scholar sees late Pope Benedict as future doctor of the church

Wednesday, January 4, 2023

New Tralee Dingle bus is an environmental cockup

The letter below appeared in The Irish Times yesterday, Tuesday. It’s worth noting the letter writer does not mention that the new buses that travel between Tralee and Dingle do not take bicycles.

Sir, – Finbar Kearns is right about the challenges of sustainable transport in rural Ireland (Letters, December 31st) but I wish to offer hope that we are not as he fears “destined to depend on significant car usage forevermore”. 

Eamon Ryan visited the Dingle Peninsula (a windy and remote, mountainous peninsula where our population is older, more sparsely populated and car-dependent than most parts) to discuss this very problem. 

Our plan to reduce the number of car-driven trips and car ownership is now a Pathfinder Project aimed at demonstrating what is actually possible for rural Ireland. Among other aims, our seven-times daily bus service around the peninsula must be improved and connections made more affordable and convenient. 

At sheltered bus-stops, mobility hubs for affordable car, bike and e-bike rental will facilitate journeys onward, and road redesign will encourage more walking and cycling. 

Car usage is not only bad for the environment, but expensive and ultimately reduces our opportunities for good health and interaction with our neighbours. Not everyone will or can switch, and most of us will retain a car, but we know that there is significant room for car shedding and a return to the joys of active travel that in fairness has stood us in good stead for many millennia. There is hope, and we must at least try! – Is mise,

Dr PEADAR Ó FIONNÁIN,

Dingle,

Co Kerry.

Tuesday, January 3, 2023

I salute the great bravery of Pussy Riot women

This week’s Independent News & Media/Mediahuis Irish regionals’ newspaper column.


Michael Commane

These days every media outlet has given much coverage to looking back on the year gone by and wondering and pondering what might happen in 2023.


In the early days of last year as life slowly began to return to normal after Covid, the Russian Army invaded Ukraine.


Yes, the world is seldom without war but the Russian invasion of Ukraine invokes in our minds the horror of World War II. 


While the West may never have warmed to Stalin, but for the Soviet Army, WW II could have been a far bigger catastrophe than it was. 


This time round the Hitler figure has taken over the levers of power in the Kremlin and it’s clear that Vladimir Putin is an autocratic dictator who allows for no opinion other than his.


What must it be like in these first days of 2023 for those who are now suffering at the hands of Putin? 


That includes women and children, the old, soldiers and yes, the soldiers too of the Russian Army.


Eight million Ukrainians have fled their homeland. 700,000 Russians have left their country since partial mobilisation was introduced.


There have been individual protestors who have shown extraordinary courage. A group of woman who have greatly impressed me are the band Pussy Riot. 


They first appeared on the scene in 2011 supporting LGBT rights and opposing the politics of Vladimir Putin and his links with the Russian Orthodox Church. 


In February 2012 they staged a performance in the Cathedral of Christ the Saviour in Moscow. It was their purpose to highlight the links between the Patriarch of the Russian Orthodox Church Kirill and President Putin. Two of the group Naezhda Tolokonnikova and Maria Alyokhina were charged with hooliganism motivated by  religious hatred.


I remember at the time being impressed with the bravery of the woman.


They have stuck to their guns, if I dare use such terminology, and have just released a new song, again, criticising the barbarity of Vladimir Putin. Their latest song is  called ‘Mama, Don’t Watch TV’. 


It gets its name from a young Russian soldier fighting in Ukraine who realises Nazis are not the problem in Ukraine and that Putin and his supporters are telling the Russian people a load of lies. He writes back to his mother to tell her the truth. It is available on YouTube. 


It’s explicit but certainly well worth watching. There are English subtitles with it.


Putin is a former KGB operative, who worked in East Germany. He’s a wily politician.


His currying favour with the Russian Orthodox Church is a master stroke.


It crossed my mind this Christmas as we got caught up in the festive extravaganza that we are beginning to forget what is happening in Ukraine. There’s a line in the song that goes: ‘Putin likes your indifference’.


Putin’s tanks must go back to base. This is aggression and all aggressors must never be allowed win.


It’s my New Year’s wish that this war will end and no more lives will be lost. The barbarity must stop and stop now.

Featured Post

Keeping our faltering faith despite a hierarchical church?

This week’s Mediahuis Irish regional newspapers’ column. Michael Commane December 8 was the traditional start to the Christmas season. It wa...